Rom-Com Redemption: 13 Box Office Flops That Are Now Cult Love Stories

Movie Reviews, Lists & Recommendations
By Sophie Hartman

Some romantic comedies may not have found success at the box office, but over time, they’ve garnered a dedicated fanbase. These films, once considered flops, are now cherished as cult classics, capturing hearts with their unique charm and wit. Let’s explore 13 such rom-com gems, each with its own story of redemption.

“Down with Love” (2003)

© Salon.com

“Down with Love” is a tongue-in-cheek homage to the romantic comedies of the 1960s. Set in New York City, it stars Renée Zellweger as a feminist author who challenges the era’s gender norms. Though initially dismissed by audiences, its playful satire and vibrant aesthetic earned it a loyal following.

The film’s bold colors and witty dialogue capture the essence of the swinging sixties. Ewan McGregor’s charismatic performance further enhances its charm. Today, “Down with Love” is celebrated for its clever take on love and independence.

With time, it’s become a favorite for fans of retro cinema.

“The Truth About Cats & Dogs” (1996)

© captainot1876

In “The Truth About Cats & Dogs,” a classic tale of mistaken identity unfolds. Uma Thurman and Janeane Garofalo star as mismatched friends entangled in a love triangle. While not a hit upon release, its relatable humor and heartfelt moments have endeared it to many.

The film’s exploration of self-esteem and friendship resonates with audiences. Garofalo’s witty yet vulnerable performance stands out, providing both comedy and depth. Its charm lies in the genuine connection between characters.

Fans have embraced its message of self-acceptance, turning it into a beloved cult classic.

“Scott Pilgrim vs. the World” (2010)

© Gateway Film Center

“Scott Pilgrim vs. the World” combines romance and video game culture in a visually stunning film. Michael Cera stars as the titular character who battles his new girlfriend’s seven evil exes. Initially overlooked, its innovative style and quirky humor have gained a dedicated fanbase.

The movie’s energetic pacing and pop culture references make it a unique viewing experience. Director Edgar Wright’s creative vision shines through in every frame.

Over time, “Scott Pilgrim” has become a cult sensation, celebrated for its originality and nostalgic appeal to video game enthusiasts and romantics alike.

“Empire Records” (1995)

© The Guardian

“Empire Records” captures the essence of 90s youth culture with its depiction of a day in the life of record store employees. Despite its initial box office failure, the film’s eclectic soundtrack and relatable characters have made it a cult favorite.

The movie’s themes of rebellion and friendship resonate with audiences, capturing the spirit of a generation. Liv Tyler and Renée Zellweger’s performances add depth to the ensemble cast.

With its iconic one-liners and memorable music, “Empire Records” continues to inspire a sense of nostalgia among fans of the decade.

“Josie and the Pussycats” (2001)

© Film Obsessive

“Josie and the Pussycats” satirizes the music industry with its tale of an all-girl band navigating fame. Initially dismissed, the film’s sharp wit and catchy soundtrack have since found an appreciative audience.

The trio’s journey through the glitzy, commercial world provides both humor and critique. Rachael Leigh Cook, Tara Reid, and Rosario Dawson bring charisma to their roles, creating a dynamic group.

Fans appreciate its playful yet insightful commentary on consumer culture, and the film has gained recognition as a clever, musical rom-com.

“The Wedding Singer” (1998)

© The Hollywood Reporter

“The Wedding Singer” transports viewers to the 80s with its nostalgic setting and charming love story. Starring Adam Sandler and Drew Barrymore, the film didn’t initially wow critics but won over fans with its heart and humor.

The chemistry between Sandler and Barrymore adds warmth to the quirky narrative. Its soundtrack, filled with 80s hits, complements the amusing and heartfelt plot.

This rom-com’s blend of humor and romance has made it a beloved classic, appreciated for its sweet take on finding love in unexpected places.

“The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement” (2004)

© D23

In “The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement,” Mia’s journey to the throne is filled with romance and laughter. Although it didn’t match the success of its predecessor, its charm and fairy-tale elements have won it a devoted fanbase.

Anne Hathaway’s delightful portrayal of the relatable princess adds to the film’s appeal. The enchanting storyline, with its lighthearted twists, offers a joyful escape.

Fans adore its whimsical take on royal life, and the movie remains a favorite for those who dream of fairy-tale adventures.

“Serendipity” (2001)

© Business Insider

“Serendipity” explores the idea of destiny with its enchanting love story set in New York City. Starring John Cusack and Kate Beckinsale, the film didn’t initially capture widespread attention but has since become a romantic favorite.

The story’s magical coincidences and charming leads create a sense of wonder. Its wintry backdrop adds to the film’s allure, making it a cozy viewing choice.

Over time, “Serendipity” has become synonymous with romantic fate, captivating audiences who believe in the power of chance encounters.

“Just Friends” (2005)

© Just Friends (2005)

“Just Friends” offers a hilarious look at love and friendship with its story of a man returning to his hometown. Ryan Reynolds’ comedic talents shine as he navigates past relationships and unrequited love.

Initially overlooked, the film’s humor and relatability have earned it a loyal following. The awkward yet endearing scenarios resonate with anyone who’s experienced unreturned feelings.

Fans appreciate its lighthearted approach to romance, and “Just Friends” has become a go-to choice for those seeking laughs and nostalgia during the holiday season.

“Can’t Hardly Wait” (1998)

© People.com

“Can’t Hardly Wait” captures the essence of teenage anticipation as graduates celebrate their last night together. Despite its modest box office results, the film’s diverse cast and relatable themes have cemented its place as a cult classic.

The movie’s focus on youthful dreams and unspoken feelings resonates with audiences. Jennifer Love Hewitt’s role as the unattainable crush adds to the film’s charm.

Viewers appreciate its nostalgic portrayal of teenage rites of passage, making it a beloved choice for fans of 90s teen rom-coms.

“Ella Enchanted” (2004)

© Scary Mommy

“Ella Enchanted” blends fantasy and romance in a whimsical adventure. Anne Hathaway stars as Ella, cursed to obey any command. Initially overlooked, the film’s enchanting story and playful humor have won it a devoted audience.

The movie’s imaginative world and endearing characters create a charming experience. Hathaway’s spirited performance brings depth to Ella’s journey of self-discovery.

Over time, “Ella Enchanted” has become a favorite for those who enjoy fairy-tale escapism, celebrating courage and individuality in a magical setting.

“Clueless” (1995)

© New York Post

“Clueless” offers a witty take on teen life, inspired by Jane Austen’s “Emma.” Alicia Silverstone stars as Cher, a fashion-forward matchmaker navigating high school social circles. Though not a box office smash, its clever script and iconic style have made it a cultural touchstone.

The film’s humor and memorable lines remain quotable decades later. Silverstone’s portrayal of Cher is both endearing and comical.

“Clueless” continues to influence fashion and pop culture, cherished for its sharp commentary on adolescent life and timeless appeal.

“10 Things I Hate About You” (1999)

© The Hollywood Reporter

“10 Things I Hate About You” reimagines Shakespeare’s “The Taming of the Shrew” in a modern high school setting. Though it wasn’t an instant hit, its witty dialogue and charming performances have earned it a cult following.

Heath Ledger and Julia Stiles shine as the leads, their chemistry sparking humorous and heartfelt moments. The film’s exploration of teenage angst and romance resonates with viewers.

Over time, it’s become a beloved classic, appreciated for its clever adaptation and nostalgic 90s vibe, capturing the spirit of youthful rebellion.